top of page

Is HB 60 Against The 1st Amendement?

With the fight against the Box Elder County data center and the Utahns rights that were lost with the new bill HB 60, I wondered if it goes against our First Amendment rights. This is my inquiry into a conversation with, ironically Ai.

​

​​

So Is it true? Here's how the conversation went

But Then I wondered, Does HB 60 violate the Utah Constitution

Basically lobbyist for this bill figured out how to cut out the "middle man", which is every single Utahn who could disagree with this project. So, is there a loophole to fight this?

How You Can Fight Back In The New Water Rights Battle. It's Petty To The Point Of Specific Wording Of How To Fight Against This Agricultural And Ecosystem Nightmare Of A Data Center.

DO NOT SKIP THIS PART!

These Are Templates You Are Welcomed To Use

How You Can Contact Local Zoning & Land Use Officials To Help This Fight

Oddly enough instead of saying the obvious how bad this data center is for Utahns with even general concerns, we as Utahns have a better chance of using peer-reviewed facts in our referendum fight that establishes a objective legal challenge the state engineer cannot ignore.

Super Important Part HERE >>>

FINAL CONCLUSION, MY OPINION:

Me: "what was the bill introduced in Utah that took away the rights of the people to speak out against the data center?"

 

7:22 AM

 

 

Google Ai:

 

The specific legislation is House Bill 60 (Water Rights Modifications), which took effect in early May. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

The bill did not directly ban speaking out, but it severely limited the public's ability to formally protest data center proposals. It restricts state officials from denying water rights to data centers based on broad "detriment to public welfare" arguments, which is the primary legal mechanism conservationists and local residents previously used to fight projects like the 40,000-acre "Stratos" campus in Box Elder County. [1, 2]

To track ongoing discussions or read the official text of the bill, check the Utah Legislature HB060 Enrolled Copy. [1]

 

AI responses may include mistakes. For legal advice, consult a professional. Learn more

 

​

6 sites

 

  • Data center: New water rights law gives less weight to pushback citing broad impact

    As of May 6, a new Utah law limits the factors the state engineer can weigh in deciding to approve or reject such requests, narrow...

     

    Utah News Dispatch

     

  • A new law that went into effect last Wednesday in Utah could make it ...

    A new law that went into effect last Wednesday in Utah could make it easier for the backers of the proposed data center in Box Eld...

     

    Facebook

     

  • New Utah law limits opposition to massive data center proposal - Axios

    State officials are no longer allowed to deny water rights based on certain public welfare arguments.

     

    Axios

     

Show all

 

​

Me: "under the Utah constitution would HB 60 go against the 1st amendment"

 

7:23 AM

​

Google Ai:

​

From a constitutional law perspective, HB 60 is unlikely to be struck down as a direct violation of the First Amendment, although it heavily alters how public feedback functions in administrative settings. [1, 2]

Because the bill restricts where and how arguments can be used in an agency decision—rather than banning citizens from expressing their opinions—courts generally view it as a modification of administrative procedure rather than a restriction on free speech. [1, 2, 3]

 

Why HB 60 Likely Avoids a First Amendment Violation

  • Speech vs. Administrative Standing: The First Amendment guarantees your right to criticize a data center or protest on public land. It does not, however, guarantee a right to legal "standing" in a highly specific state agency proceeding. Courts typically rule that states have broad authority to decide who counts as an "interested party" in their own regulatory hearings.

  • No Content or Viewpoint Discrimination: The text of HB 60 Enrolled Copy does not explicitly target anti-data-center speech. It limits anyone from using broad "public welfare" claims to block a water transfer, whether they are an environmentalist, a corporate competitor, or a regular citizen.

  • The Right to Protest Remains: Local advocacy groups, like Grow the Flow Utah, note that citizens can still legally submit formal protests. The law simply instructs the State Engineer to ignore comments that do not deal strictly with water quality, quantity, or direct availability. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]

 

The Regulatory "Chilling Effect"

While the law passes technical constitutional hurdles, civil liberties and environmental groups argue it creates a "chilling effect" on public participation. By removing "public welfare" from the evaluation criteria and requiring a citizen to prove a "particularized injury" to challenge a decision in court, the state has effectively shut down the primary avenue for community-led resistance. It is a functional restriction on public influence, achieved through narrowing bureaucratic rules rather than banning speech outright. [1, 2, 3, 4]

Would you like to explore how community groups are adjusting their legal strategies under these new rules, or look into the current water application status of the Box Elder data center campus? [1]

 

AI responses may include mistakes. For legal advice, consult a professional. Learn more

 

​

8 sites

 

  • Enrolled Copy H.B. 60 - Utah Legislature

    Appropriation -- Manner of acquiring water rights. 30 (1) A person may acquire a right to the use of the unappropriated public wat...

     

    Utah Legislature (.gov)

     

  • You Filed A Formal Protest Against the Stratos Project's Water Rights ...

    While HB 60 changes the legal framework around court challenges and narrows the scope of arguments the State Engineer can formally...

     

    Grow The Flow - Utah

     

  • Water Rights Amendments - Alliance for a Better Utah

    This bill changes how the state engineer reviews applications to use Utah's public water, including limiting the grounds on which ...

     

    Alliance for a Better Utah

     

Show all

 

​​

​

​

Me: does HB 50 violate any terms in the Utah constitution 

​

Note: I made a typo here but Ai understood that.

 

7:24 AM

 

Google Ai:

 

Assuming you are continuing the discussion about the data center water rights bill (House Bill 60, which you mentioned as HB 50), it is highly unlikely to violate the Utah Constitution, though legal experts note it pushes the boundaries of administrative law. [1]

(Note: If you meant the actual 2026 Utah HB 50 regarding Child Protection Ombudsman, that is an unrelated bill with no constitutional controversies. The analysis below focuses on the water/data center bill, HB 60). [1, 2, 3]

If a legal challenge were brought against HB 60 under the Utah Constitution, it would likely be argued under two specific provisions:

 

1. The Right to Petition the Government (Article I, Section 1)

  • The Claim: The Utah Constitution protects the inherent right to "petition for a redress of grievances." Opponents argue that by deleting "public welfare" from the reasons a citizen can protest a water change application, the state is blocking citizens from petitioning an agency.

  • The Reality: The Utah Supreme Court generally gives the Legislature immense deference to write the rules for state agencies. Courts usually rule that as long as citizens can still lobby their lawmakers or sue if they suffer direct financial/property damage, restricting the grounds for a bureaucratic protest does not violate the constitutional right to petition. [1]

 

2. The Public Trust Doctrine

  • The Claim: Under natural resource law and implied constitutional principles, the State of Utah holds public water bodies (like the Great Salt Lake) "in trust" for the benefit of all citizens. Advocacy groups argue that forcing the State Engineer to ignore massive data center water depletions violates the state’s constitutional duty to protect shared public assets.

  • The Reality: Utah's application of the Public Trust Doctrine is historically narrow compared to states like California. The Utah Legislature has broad authority to define what constitutes a "beneficial use" of water, and they have explicitly codified industrial development as a beneficial use. [1, 2]

 

A New Hurdle for Future Lawsuits [1]

Even if an environmental group wanted to sue the state claiming HB 60 violates the Utah Constitution, a newly established legislative rule routes constitutional challenges against state laws to a specialized three-judge "constitutional court" panel. This panel makes it much harder for a single local district judge to pause or strike down controversial laws passed by the legislature. [1, 2]

If you would like to look into the Public Trust Doctrine in Utah or see the exact text of the Utah Declaration of Rights, let me know! 

 

AI responses may include mistakes. For legal advice, consult a professional. Learn more

​​

Me: is there any loophole that could win in a law suit to fight against HB 60

 

7:26 AM

​​

Google Ai:

​

While there is no magic "loophole" that will instantly strike down HB 60, top environmental attorneys in Utah are actively using two specific legal workarounds to bypass the law's restrictions. [1]

Because HB 60 only limits how the State Engineer handles protests, it leaves massive vulnerabilities outside of that office. Opponents are pivoting away from broad "public welfare" arguments and attacking the data center via the following strategies: [1, 2, 3, 4]

 

1. The "Adjacent Injury" Workaround (Retaining Standing)

HB 60 attempts to block lawsuits by requiring a challenger to prove a "particularized injury" rather than a general concern about the environment. [1, 2]

  • The Strategy: Lawsuits will not be filed by regional environmental groups arguing for the Great Salt Lake. Instead, they will be filed on behalf of adjacent property owners, local farmers, or culinary water districts.

  • How it works: If a local farmer can show that a data center's massive groundwater pumping will lower the water table and dry up their specific, existing physical well, they still have unquestionable legal standing to sue under Utah law. HB 60 cannot strip away a person's private property rights. [1, 2, 3, 4]

 

2. The "Feasibility and Speculation" Rule (Still Intact)

Attorneys for Friends of the Great Salt Lake have noted that while HB 60 gutted the "public welfare" clause, it did not alter other strict criteria that water applications must meet under Utah Code § 73-3-8. [1, 2]

  • The Strategy: Protesters are attacking the technical feasibility and "speculative" nature of the Stratos project's application.

  • How it works: Utah law states an applicant must prove they have an immediate, non-speculative plan to put the water to beneficial use, and that they have the financial and physical capability to construct the project. Because the Stratos project’s initial paperwork lacked granular technical data center layouts, power infrastructure routing, and exact water recycling specs, lawyers can argue the application is legally "speculative" and must be denied on purely technical grounds—completely bypassing HB 60. [1, 2, 3, 4]

 

3. Exploiting the "Other Agency" Hand-Off

HB 60 states that the State Engineer cannot reject a water application based on public welfare if the issue is "better addressed by another state agency." [1, 2]

  • The Strategy: This language unintentionally opens a loophole for multi-agency legal warfare.

  • How it works: Instead of fighting the Division of Water Rights, opposition groups can file administrative challenges and lawsuits through the Utah Division of Air Quality (DAQ) or the Utah Division of Water Quality (DWQ). Because data centers require massive, polluting diesel backup generators and create thermal water pollution, activists can use those specific agency frameworks to block the project's environmental permits, achieving the same end goal. [1]

 

The Power of "Administrative Clogging"

As organizations like Grow the Flow Utah have pointed out, the ultimate practical loophole is numbers. HB 60 requires the State Engineer to physically process every single protest filed. When over 3,800 citizens filed formal protests against the Stratos project in May, the sheer administrative burden forced the developers to panic and withdraw their application entirely. [1, 2, 3, 4]

If you'd like, I can help you look up how to draft a technically compliant water protest that fits within these new legal boundaries, or track when the Stratos developers plan to refile their application. [, 2]

 

AI responses may include mistakes. For legal advice, consult a professional. Learn more

​

 

12 sites

 

  • You Filed A Formal Protest Against the Stratos Project's Water Rights ...

    While HB 60 changes the legal framework around court challenges and narrows the scope of arguments the State Engineer can formally...

     

    Grow The Flow - Utah

     

  • Press Release: Stratos Developers Withdraw Water Rights Applications ...

    Press Release: Stratos Developers Withdraw Water Rights Applications After Thousands of Protests, Plan to Refile - Grow The Flow -

     

    Grow The Flow - Utah

     

  • HB 60 Water Rights Amendments - Utah Legislature

    73-3-7 . Protests. (1) Any Subject to Subsection (2) , a person interested may file a protest with the state. engineer: (a) within...

     

    Utah Legislature (.gov)

     

Show all

 

ME: yes but also find a way to fight against this hb60

 

7:28 AM

​

Google Ai:

​

To effectively fight against HB 60 and the data center developers trying to use it, activists, citizens, and environmental groups are using a multi-pronged approach that blends technical water strategy, local zoning pressure, and public mobilization.

​

Because HB 60 narrowly channels protests, the strategy is to attack the project outside of the loophole-limited state engineer's office. You can take action or participate in the pushback through several specific methods. [1, 2]

 

1. File a "HB 60-Compliant" Water Protest [1]

HB 60 states that the State Engineer must ignore protests that focus on broad environmental impacts or "public welfare". However, the State Engineer must still legally process and rule on protests that focus strictly on water quantity, quality, and availability. [1, 2, 3]

  • The Action: If the Stratos data center developers refile their application, citizens should still file thousands of formal protests, but change the wording.

  • The Formula: Instead of writing "Save the Great Salt Lake", the protest text must strictly argue technical water availability. For example: "The requested volume of water exceeds the safe yield of the aquifer, which will directly impair the water availability and quality of municipal/agricultural wells in the surrounding basin." This forces the State Engineer to legally consider the protest under the new rules. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

 

2. Join Up with Local Grassroots Groups

Several Utah-based environmental and civic organizations are spearheading the legal and educational pushback against HB 60 and the Box Elder data center campus. [1]

 

3. Attend Active Public Demonstrations

Public outcry remains a powerful political weapon, even if the regulatory process was narrowed. The mass influx of protests and public rallies is what initially forced developers to pivot their approach. [1]

  • Upcoming Event: A large-scale public rally is scheduled for Saturday, May 23 at 11:00 AM at the Utah State Capitol steps to speak out against the Stratos data center and the restrictions of HB 60. Showing up in numbers forces the issue to remain visible in the media and puts pressure on local officials. [1, 2]

 

4. Pressure Local Officials on Land Use and Zoning

HB 60 only limits the State Engineer’s authority over water rights; it does not strip local county or city governments of their zoning and land-use powers. [, 2]

  • The Action: Lobby the Box Elder County Commissioners and city councils where the project is proposed. Local governments still hold the authority to deny conditional use permits, building permits, or strict zoning approvals based on infrastructure constraints, noise from cooling systems, and local traffic. If the county denies the land use, a water permit is useless to the developers. [1]

 

5. Pivot the Fight to Air Quality Permits [1]

HB 60 explicitly states that the State Engineer cannot reject a water right if the concern falls under the jurisdiction of another agency. [1]

  • The Action: Watch for the project’s permit applications with the Utah Division of Air Quality (DAQ). Data centers require massive arrays of industrial diesel generators for backup power. Opponents can legally flood the DAQ with protests regarding air emissions, particulate matter, and the impact of diesel smoke on the Wasatch Front airshed—an avenue completely untouched by HB 60. [1, 2]

Would you like help finding templates for technically worded water protests, or more details on how to contact Box Elder County planning officials to object to the zoning permits? [1]

 

12 sites

 

  • Update on HB 60 - Grow The Flow - Utah

    The State Engineer can deny a water right or change application if it is detrimental to the public welfare—which allows the State ...

     

    Grow The Flow - Utah

     

  • The next data center protest is May 23 at 11 am at the Utah State Capitol ...

    On Monday 5/4/26, everyday Utahn's showed up to fight the largest data center project in the world in Box Elder County, in light o...

     

    0:44

     

    Instagram·Caroline Gleich

     

  • Hundreds of Utahns file to block Kevin O'Leary's proposed massive data ...

    Gov. Spencer Cox and other Utah leaders have previously called any claims that data centers are major water users “a big misnomer ...

     

    The Salt Lake Tribune

     

Show all

 

Me: Let me see both and the water rights protest you were stating

7:31 AM

​

Here is the practical toolkit to fight back under the new rules imposed by HB 60, including the specific technical text needed to ensure your water protests cannot legally be ignored, and the contact channels for the local officials who control the project's land-use permits.

 

 

Part 1: The Technically Worded Water Protest Template

Because HB 60 strips away the "public welfare" and broad environmental clauses, your protest must strictly focus on water availability, technical feasibility, and depletion metrics.

When the Stratos project developers refile their applications on the Utah Division of Water Rights Portal, choose or combine the templates below.

 

Template A: For the General Public (Focus on Missing Feasibility Data)

 

"I respectfully protest this application on the grounds of insufficient data regarding physical and economic feasibility under Utah Code § 73-3-8. The applicant has failed to provide a localized, complete water budget justifying the consumptive use of the proposed multi-gigawatt facility. Furthermore, there is insufficient evidence that the underlying aquifer possesses the safe yield to sustain this volume without creating an unstudied hydrologic deficit. I request that the State Engineer require an independent, third-party hydrological analysis and grant a public hearing before any decision is made."

 

Template B: For Surrounding Well-Owners & Farmers (The "Adjacent Injury" Angle)

 

"As a property owner/water right holder in the local basin, I protest this application due to immediate risk of impairment. The high-volume groundwater extraction proposed by this project poses a direct threat to the localized water table, hydrostatic pressure, and safe yield of existing culinary and agricultural wells. The application fails to analyze how this continuous industrial drawdown will affect the physical availability and quality of water in neighboring rights. I request a formal administrative hearing."

  • Cost to File Online: $15.00.

  • Free Alternative: Email your statement directly to waterrights@utah.gov. State clearly in the subject line: Protest — Change Application [Insert Number], Water Right 13-4148. Always include your full name, mailing address, and explicitly state "I am requesting a hearing."

 

 

Part 2: Targeting Local Zoning & Land Use Officials

HB 60 stops the State Engineer from looking at the big picture, but it does not strip Box Elder County of its zoning and local land control. If the local government denies building or zoning permits, the data center cannot be built, regardless of their water status.

You can contact the local decision-makers using the channels below to voice opposition regarding noise from massive cooling systems, infrastructure strain, and local land misuse.

 

Box Elder County Commissioners (The Final Local Vote)

 

Box Elder Community Development / Planning & Zoning

The Planning Commission evaluates the project's master plan and zoning modifications.

  • Planning Secretary (Diane Fuhriman): dfuhriman@boxeldercountyut.gov | 435-734-3354

  • County Planner (Marcus Wager): 435-734-3308

  • County Planner (Destin Christiansen): 435-695-2547

 

What to Say to County Officials:

When writing or calling, focus entirely on local impacts:

  • Demand they protect local agricultural zones from industrial sprawl.

  • Object to the extreme power grid strain that could destabilize local residential utility rates.

  • Highlight the lack of transparent, long-term economic safeguards for local taxpayers if the facility is abandoned.

To see what the immense scope of the proposed 40,000-acre project actually looks like, review the latest site designs and community layout plans:

 

 

2:00

 

 

New renderings released for Box Elder County data center as water rights ...

 

 

 

FOX 13 News Utah

YouTube• May 18, 2026

If you want to coordinate with others, look into the ongoing citizen referendum tracking being organized by local advocacy groups. Let me know if you would like me to track down the dates for the next Box Elder Planning Commission public comment meeting.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

15 sites

 

  • How to Engage on the Box Elder County Data Center Proposal

    We Need Your Help * Enter the application number: Water Right 13-4148. Click “Get Info” “Change application” will auto-fill under ...

     

    Grow The Flow - Utah

     

  • Box Elder County commissioners on May 4 unanimously approved ...

    *** Data Center-Related Update-2040 Comp Plan Amendment *** The City Council is expected to vote on the 2040 Comp Plan amendment i...

     

    Facebook

     

  • New water rights application filed for data center plans; details of proposed facility emerge

    "This application lacks sufficient detail about proposed water consumption. Approval of this application would increase depletion,

     

    KSL.com

     

Show all

 

to the new water rights petition can you add any scholarly articles to give evidence for concern that would fit what you were saying for strategy

 

7:35 AM

Integrating peer-reviewed, academic evidence directly into your petition is the most effective way to exploit the "technical feasibility" workaround. Because HB 60 forces the state engineer to ignore generalized concerns, providing specific, quantifiable numbers from published research establishes an objective legal challenge regarding the physical limitations of the basin. [1, 2, 3]

 

Expanded, Evidence-Backed Water Rights Protest Template

When filing your protest on the Utah Division of Water Rights portal or emailing waterrights@utah.gov, copy and adapt the comprehensive text below: [1]

 

SUBJECT: Formal Protest of Change Application, Application Number a54385 associated with Water Right  13-4148

​

To the Utah State Engineer:

​

Pursuant to Utah Code §§ 73-3-3 and 73-3-8, I submit this formal protest and explicitly request a public administrative hearing. Under the restrictive administrative parameters codified by HB 60, this protest is strictly limited to the technical issues of localized water availability, hydrologic deficit, physical infeasibility, and immediate impairment of existing rights.

​

I request that the State Engineer deny this application based on the following peer-reviewed, scientific evidence demonstrating that the basin cannot support this project’s physical scope:

​

1. Failure to Demonstrate Physical Feasibility Under Unprecedented System Demands


The applicant has failed to provide a localized, audited water budget detailing the true consumptive use of a facility of this magnitude. According to a comprehensive 2026 study published in PLOS Water, "Four water insecurity concerns about datacenters driving the AI revolution," rapid hyperscale development drastically undermines local water resilience and leads to unsustainable localized depletions. Furthermore, technical research compiled by the University of Michigan STPP Program (2025) notes a severe, unavoidable "Resource Efficiency Trade-Off". If the applicant claims to use an energy-dense closed-loop cooling system to mitigate water draw, they must prove the physical feasibility of handling the massive energy-to-water ratio without overwhelming localized grid systems or altering the surrounding microclimate dew point. The complete lack of granular infrastructure specifications in this application makes a determination of physical feasibility impossible under Utah Code § 73-3-8. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]

​

2. Documented Regional Hydrologic Deficit and Aquifer Stress


The continuous industrial drawdown required by a multi-gigawatt facility threatens the hydrostatic pressure and physical availability of surrounding agricultural and culinary wells. Academic consensus established in "Water Development, Consumptive Water Uses, and the Great Salt Lake" (Utah State University) documents that the broader watershed is already facing an unsustainable anthropogenic depletion rate of roughly 39%. Adding a high-volume industrial consumer into a terminal basin currently experiencing a steep water balance deficit—as tracked by Abbott et al. via ScienceDirect—will physically impair existing prior-appropriation water rights by accelerating the decline of the localized water table. [1, 2, 3, 4]

​

Conclusion and Request for Action
Because peer-reviewed science proves that high-volume industrial cooling in an over-allocated, arid basin directly threatens the baseline quantity and physical flow of neighboring rights, the State Engineer cannot legally declare that there is unappropriated water available for this project. I request that the applicant be ordered to provide independent, third-party hydrological modeling to address these specific scholarly findings before this application is given any further administrative consideration. [1, 2, 3]

​

Respectfully submitted,

[Your Name]
[Your Physical Utah Address]
[Your Contact Information] [1, 2]

 

__________________________________________

Why This Specific Evidence Defeats HB 60

​

  • It isolates the State Engineer: By citing the PLOS Water and University of Michigan studies, you are forcing the state engineer to make a decision based purely on engineering and physical capacity—rules they are still required to enforce.

  • It bypasses the "Public Welfare" trap: You aren't arguing that the data center is "bad for the community" (which HB 60 bans you from doing). You are arguing that the laws of physics and hydrology prove the water physically is not there to safely allocate without drying up older water rights. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]

​

If you would like, I can track down the exact water right numbers or change application code for the Box Elder project so you can fill in the bracketed information precisely! [1]

 

AI responses may include mistakes. For legal advice, consult a professional. Learn more

 

 

 

 

 

 

11 sites

 

  • Hundreds of Utahns file to block Kevin O'Leary's proposed massive data ...

    We need our lake back.” Nearly all of the roughly 400 protests sent to the division expressed concerns over Utah's water shortages...

     

    The Salt Lake Tribune

     

  • WHAT HAPPENS WHEN DATA CENTERS COME TO TOWN?

    High Resource Consumption: A single data center can consume up to 2 megawatt hours of power—equivalent to the power used by 2,000 ...

     

    Science, Technology and Public Policy (STPP)

     

  • What’s Up With Mr. Wonderful’s Utah Data Center?

    Environmental fears, ancestral lands. Utah is facing a critical water shortage driven by the warmest winter in over a century, wit...

     

    Rolling Stone

     

Show all

 

ME: yes

7:39 AM

​

Google Ai:

​

To file an official protest under the narrow rules of HB 60, you must target the active filings currently open for public pushback. [1]

The developers are attempting a strategy of accumulating small water rights. The first massive 1,900 acre-foot application (Water Right 13-4148, Change Application a54385) was withdrawn by Bar H Ranch due to public backlash, but a second active application has been surfaced by an entity named Murray Hollow L.C.. [1, 2, 3, 4]

 

Active Application Details for Your Protest

  • Change Application Number: a54536 (or the related Murray Hollow filing submitted late April).

  • Proposed Use: Changing historical stock watering and domestic use to industrial use for a natural gas-fired power plant and associated data center in "Wonder Valley" (the Stratos project site).

  • Active Protest Window: Open right now. Protests are legally accepted until June 16, 2026. [1, 3, 4]

 

 

Official Water Rights Protest Template

(With Active Case Numbers & Citations)

​

You can file this directly on the Utah Division of Water Rights Online Portal or by emailing waterrights@utah.gov. [1, 2]

 

SUBJECT: Formal Protest of Change Application a54536 associated with the Stratos Project Data Center / Murray Hollow L.C. [1, 2]

​

To the Utah State Engineer:

Pursuant to Utah Code §§ 73-3-3 and 73-3-8, I submit this formal protest regarding the proposed transfer of water to industrial use for power generation and data center operations in Box Elder County. I explicitly request a formal administrative hearing. [, 2, 3]

​

Under the restrictive administrative parameters codified by HB 60, this protest is strictly limited to the technical criteria of localized water availability, hydrologic deficit, physical infeasibility, and the immediate impairment of prior-appropriation rights. I request that the State Engineer deny this application based on the following peer-reviewed, scientific evidence: [1, 2]

​

1. Failure to Demonstrate Physical Feasibility Under Systems Stress
The applicant has failed to provide a localized, audited water budget detailing the true consumptive use of a facility of this magnitude. According to a comprehensive 2026 study published in PLOS Water, "Four water insecurity concerns about datacenters driving the AI revolution," rapid hyperscale development drastically undermines local water resilience, causing intense localized depletions. Furthermore, technical research compiled by the University of Michigan STPP Program (2025) notes an extreme "Resource Efficiency Trade-Off" regarding cooling and power grid strain. Because the applicant proposes an intensive industrial cooling source alongside a natural gas power plant, they have provided no evidence that the underlying basin has the physical or infrastructure capacity to sustain this use without degrading local systems. [1, 2]

​

2. Documented Regional Hydrologic Deficit and Well Impairment
The high-volume industrial extraction proposed threatens the hydrostatic pressure and physical availability of surrounding agricultural and culinary wells in Area 13 (Hansel Valley, Snowville, Howell, and Plymouth). Academic consensus established in "Water Development, Consumptive Water Uses, and the Great Salt Lake" (Utah State University) documents that the broader watershed is already over-allocated and facing an unsustainable anthropogenic depletion rate of roughly 39%. Adding a high-volume industrial consumer into a terminal basin currently experiencing a steep water balance deficit—as tracked by Abbott et al. via ScienceDirect—will physically impair existing prior-appropriation water rights by accelerating the decline of the localized water table. [1, 2]

​

Conclusion and Request for Action
Because peer-reviewed science proves that high-volume industrial cooling in an over-allocated, arid basin directly threatens the baseline quantity and physical flow of neighboring rights, the State Engineer cannot legally declare that there is unappropriated water available for this project. I request that the applicant be ordered to provide independent, third-party hydrological modeling to address these specific scholarly findings before this application is given any further administrative consideration. [1]

​

Respectfully submitted,

[Your Name]
[Your Physical Utah Address]
[Your Contact Information]

 

 

Remember the Rules of the Fight:

  1. The $15 Fee: If filing via the state portal, a $15 fee is required to officially register the protest.

  2. If You Own a Local Well: If you own a well or property in Box Elder County, explicitly state that in the first paragraph. Under HB 60, local well-owners have the highest legal standing to bypass the law's restrictions. [1]

​​

​

​

​

​

So This Is What I Think Folks:

​

With evil politics and specific wording to fight legal challenges, we are going to have to fine tune our phrases to specifically fight this Data Center. O' Leary can pay whoever to fight this for him because he is a lazy billionaire with time and money.

 

Though it may seem petty to have to get to those specifics, like being in a fight with your gas lighting ex-boyfriend with no matter what you say they won't listen.

 

It's what we are going to have to do to show they legally can not go around us and hopefully save our state.

 

Our governor ok'd and has sold his soul to the highest bidder to come purchase and destroy Utah lands and ecosystems to fill the void in his ego and allow his cronies, a small group of what maybe 7+ people to say what and how Utah will be destroyed now?​

 

It's up to us to say NO! Speak Out Any Way You Can!

​

​

​​

bottom of page